Fido Between Two Kinds of School
Is Fido one of these?
Parents who have read about a software-led school, such as the Alpha School in the US, sometimes ask whether Fido is one. Parents drawn to democratic schools, where children decide what and whether they learn, ask the same question from the other side. The short answer is no to both. Fido shares something with each, and it leaves something out of each on purpose.
Fido Alongside Other Schools sets Fido beside five familiar models. This article goes one level deeper on two kinds of school. It asks three questions every school answers: who decides what a child learns and when, whether every child is promised a floor, and what the adults are for. Then it says why Fido answers them as it does, and what about its answers is untested.
The rule of the series holds here too. Both kinds of school run today; Fido is a design with a first pilot. We describe the other schools as their own advocates do, and we say what about Fido is decided, planned, or still open.
Two Kinds of School, in Their Own Words
Both kinds of school depart from the ordinary school day, in which a whole class moves at one pace and learns for the grade. Each departs from it in its own consistent way.
The software-led school. Academics run on adaptive learning software, in a short, focused block each morning. Its best-known example speaks of about two hours a day. Each child moves on once they have mastered a topic, not when the calendar says so. The adults are called guides. The software carries the content, so the guides' job is motivation and relationship rather than explaining. The afternoons belong to workshops away from the screen. Its advocates promise efficiency: when the academic core is done well and quickly, the rest of the day is free for other things.
The democratic school. Here the children decide what they do with their day, including whether and when they learn to read, write, and calculate. There are no compulsory lessons, and adults teach when a child asks. The school governs itself in a meeting where each child and each adult has one vote. Schools in the Sudbury tradition are its best-known form. Their advocates promise trust: given time, a child's curiosity finds its way, and children learn to govern themselves by doing it.
Both are serious answers, and families choose them for good reasons. They differ most in who decides. In the one, software sets the sequence of academic work and adults keep the child going. In the other, the child decides nearly everything, and the community decides the rules. Fido answers each question separately, and its answers do not all fall on one side.
What Fido Shares with the Software-Led School
What Fido shares with the software-led school is not a model but two
ideas from learning research: mastery learning and
spaced practice. A child moves on once a topic is
secure, so gaps do not travel along. What has been learned comes back
before it fades. At Fido both are carried by the
Fido also keeps the daily dose bounded: about one hour in primary school, two in the middle years, two to three in the upper years. Software is good at practice that depends on a sequence. It places each child by what they can show and corrects every answer at once. Kept to a bounded dose, it frees the adults from correcting and leaves the rest of the day for other kinds of learning. Three things Fido deliberately does differently.
Software for one kind of learning. The engine carries facts, procedures, and the parts of understanding that an exercise can check. Judging a case, a craft in the hands, a project of one's own, how people treat each other: these need a person in the room or the child's own time. So Fido's day has three modes, each built for the kinds of knowledge it serves, as told in Seven Kinds of Knowledge and the Curriculum Map.
Adults who also teach a subject. In the mastery mode Fido keeps the division the software-led school makes: the guide does not reteach the content, but finds out why a child is stuck. Beyond that, Fido plans more for its adults. Every child is to meet, each week, an adult with real command of each core area: mathematics and science, language and literature, history and society. A child should see an adult who cares about a subject, and software cannot show that.
Speed does not buy the afternoon. At Fido, finishing the morning's work faster earns neither a longer afternoon nor a reward. A child who gains time in a subject keeps most of it as their own, inside academic work, to go further or deeper from a few offers. The afternoon is the same for every child. It exists because some learning happens only there, not as payment for the morning. Our reason: free time paid for speed could teach a child that learning is a cost to pay down, and it could invite rushing. For the same reason, gained time counts only on progress that has lasted. The rule is decided but not yet built into the software; until it is, guides are to apply it by hand.
What Fido Shares with the Democratic School
From the democratic school, Fido shares its starting point: trust in the child. A child's curiosity and judgment are what learning is built from, not a fault to be corrected. Three things follow at Fido, as they do there.
Time that is the child's. Every day, every child has time that no adult plans: to read anything, build something, follow an interest, play, or do nothing in particular. The school provides rooms, materials, and adults on request, not a program. And it guards this time against being filled up again with activities the school could take credit for.
Real responsibility. As they grow, children are to run real parts of the school: shared spaces and plants in primary school, later the library, the school store, and tutoring for younger children, and in the upper years budgets for projects and work with outside partners. Each task has a stated outcome and real consequences, so it is responsibility, not a game of it.
A real say. Children help make the rules they live under, with more weight as they grow older. How that works, and why it stops short of full self-government, is told in Living Together.
What Fido does not share is one principle: that whether and when a
child learns to read, write, and calculate is left to the child. Fido
holds a different commitment. Every child it admits is owed a
This is a difference in what the school promises, not a verdict on children who learn at democratic schools. A school that leaves the choice to the child can trust each child's timing. A school that promises a floor to every child cannot wait for it. Above the floor, the roles turn around. There the child leads, the school's job is to inspire rather than push, and the climb goes as high as the child wants.
Who Decides What at Fido
Set side by side, Fido's answers give each decision to whoever is best placed for that kind of learning: the software, the child, or the adults.
The software decides inside a course: which card comes next, when something comes back before it fades, and when the next row opens. Learners of any age know what they prefer better than they know which practice will make it last. So inside a course, the order is not the child's to choose.
The child decides which course to work on today and in which order the subjects come. They decide what to do with time they gain, and with the free part of every day. Above the floor, they decide how far to climb.
The adults answer for the
This is not a compromise, if a compromise means half of each: half the freedom, half the structure. In its own territory each side has the whole. The practice is fully structured, and the free time is fully free. Each tradition is given the part of the day where it is strongest, and the school's job is to keep each part what it is.
Today the division runs in part. In the app, the
What Is Untested
Both kinds of school have run for years. Fido has a design and a first pilot. Its position between them is a reasoned bet, and several parts of it are untested.
- Whether own time pulls as strongly. A longer afternoon is a strong reason to focus in the morning. Fido gives it up and bets that a real say over one's own learning carries much of the same pull. The first class is the first chance to see.
- A child who does not do the day's work. A child who works slowly loses nothing in the afternoon. For a child who does not do the work at all, two answers are on the table: a guided make-up session, or a conversation with the guide and no cost to the afternoon. We have not chosen.
- Whether the dose is enough. The academic core, including everything the state curriculum asks, has to fit into a bounded daily dose without eating into the rest of the day. Until a school runs it, that is a judgment.
- How gained time is shared. How much of it a child keeps, how much goes to trying something new, and how much to a subject where they are behind are starting values. They are to be adjusted in the open as evidence comes in.
- Adults who can do both. Adults who motivate well and also know a subject deeply are harder to find than either. Whether a school of our size can staff every team that way is not yet known.
The first pilot runs inside an existing school, as told in The Pilot at an Existing School. It gives us feedback on the practice. It cannot show whether the whole design holds.
This article closes the chapter on whom Fido is for, which opens with Who Fido Is For, and What It Owes. How Fido sits beside the regular school, Montessori, and a public school that works by mastery without software is told in Fido Alongside Other Schools.
Do you know one of these schools from the inside, and see it differently? Write to us.